Call For A Free Consultation 212-257-8321

Habla Español

What Happens If the Officer Does Not Show Up to My TVB Hearing?

What Happens If the Officer Does Not Show Up to My TVB Hearing?

If the officer does not show up to your TVB hearing in New York City, the DMV rule in 15 NYCRR 124.9 says the ticket is dismissed unless the officer gave at least seven days’ notice or missed it for an excused reason. In that case the judge usually adjourns. A second unexcused absence generally means dismissal.

An officer no-show is one of the most searched questions about the Traffic Violations Bureau, and one of the most misunderstood. It is a real rule with real limits, and it is never something a driver can count on. Craig M. Bondy of The Law Office of Craig Bondy, in Lower Manhattan, represents drivers at TVB hearings for tickets written across the five boroughs. Our NYC traffic ticket lawyer page explains how the practice prepares these cases.

If you have a TVB hearing coming up, contact our office for a free, no-obligation ticket evaluation before the hearing date.

What Does the DMV Rule Say When the Officer Does Not Appear?

Under 15 NYCRR 124.9(a), if the police officer does not appear for a TVB hearing without giving the bureau at least seven days’ notice, the charge is dismissed, unless the absence resulted from a family death, the officer’s illness or injury, an emergency response, a conflicting court appearance, or a police emergency.

That rule has two parts, and both matter. First, an officer who notifies TVB at least seven days ahead is not treated as an unexcused no-show, so the hearing is normally rescheduled. Second, even without notice, the officer’s absence is excused if it came from one of five listed reasons:

  • a death in the officer’s family;
  • the officer’s illness or injury;
  • the officer being required to respond immediately to a crime or violation;
  • a conflicting court appearance by the officer; or
  • a police emergency.

When one of those applies, the administrative law judge adjourns the hearing to a new date instead of dismissing the ticket. Officers in New York City also appear in Criminal Court and respond to emergencies, so an excused first absence is always possible.

What Happens If the Officer Misses the Rescheduled Hearing Too?

Under 15 NYCRR 124.9(d), if a TVB hearing was adjourned because of the officer’s excused absence and the officer then misses the adjourned hearing without seven days’ notice, the charge is dismissed. The excuses no longer apply. The only exception is if the judge finds that dismissal would create a substantial traffic safety hazard.

This is the rule behind the familiar idea that the officer gets one excused miss. The second absence is treated very differently from the first. Even so, the judge keeps the safety-hazard exception, and the officer can still give seven days’ notice before the second date. A driver should arrive at every hearing date ready to go forward with the officer present.

Are There Tickets Where the First No-Show Never Leads to Dismissal?

Yes. Under 15 NYCRR 124.9(b), the first officer no-show cannot lead to dismissal when the driver is required to appear in person under 15 NYCRR 123.5. That covers serious speeding, persistent violators, junior license holders, and drivers facing a mandatory suspension or revocation.

Under 15 NYCRR 123.5, a driver must appear in person before an administrative law judge, and cannot plead guilty by mail, when:

  • a conviction would make the driver a persistent violator under the DMV point rules in 15 NYCRR Part 131;
  • a conviction would require a mandatory suspension or revocation;
  • the ticket charges speeding 30 mph or more over the limit, or the driver was convicted of speeding in the past six months;
  • the ticket charges unlicensed driving under VTL 509 and the driver has two prior VTL 509 convictions in 10 years;
  • the driver holds a junior license (class DJ or MJ) or a license issued under VTL 530 or 1196 (restricted or conditional licenses);
  • the license was already suspended or revoked when the ticket was written; or
  • the DMV Commissioner requires an appearance based on the facts of the case.

These are the tickets with the most at stake, and they are exactly the ones where an officer’s first absence will not end the case.

Can the Judge Change These Rules?

Yes, within limits. Under 15 NYCRR 124.9(c), the TVB administrative law judge may vary the officer no-show procedures in unusual or exceptional circumstances. That discretion is one reason a no-show is never a guaranteed dismissal, even when the rule seems to apply.

The judge also decides, on the record, whether the officer’s absence fits one of the excused reasons. That makes the hearing record important on the day of the adjournment, not just on the day of the trial.

Should I Object If the Judge Adjourns Because the Officer Is Absent?

Yes. If the officer is absent and the judge adjourns instead of dismissing, ask on the record why the officer is absent and object if no excused reason is given. In a 2018 Appellate Division case, a driver who stayed silent at the adjournment lost the argument later, after the officer could not recall why he missed it.

In Matter of Lochwyn v New York State Department of Motor Vehicles, 159 AD3d 702 (2d Dept 2018), the officer missed the first TVB hearing and the judge adjourned. The driver did not object. At the next hearing, the officer testified and could not recall why he had been absent. The driver moved to dismiss under 15 NYCRR 124.9, but the court upheld the conviction, pointing out that the driver had not challenged the adjournment when it was granted and rejecting the argument in any event.

The practical lesson for a TVB hearing in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, or Staten Island:

  • When the officer’s case is called and no officer is present, listen to what the judge says about the reason.
  • If no reason is stated, ask for it on the record, politely and briefly.
  • If the stated reason is not one of the five excused reasons and the officer gave no seven days’ notice, object to the adjournment and ask for dismissal under 15 NYCRR 124.9(a).
  • Write down the date, the judge’s name, and what was said, since that record supports any later appeal.

What Happens If I Do Not Show Up Instead?

The rule for drivers is much harsher. Under 15 NYCRR 124.8, a driver who is not present within one hour after the scheduled TVB hearing time is treated as having failed to appear, and the driver’s license is suspended until a rescheduled hearing is held or security is posted at the judge’s discretion.

Over time, an unanswered or missed TVB case can also end in a default conviction. The best protection is the one reschedule the DMV allows: a TVB hearing can be rescheduled once, to a date within 20 months of the ticket, with a mailed request received at least 10 days before the hearing or a phone request at least 24 hours before. Our post on what happens if you miss a TVB hearing in NYC covers the driver’s side in detail.

Can I Plan on the Officer Not Showing Up?

No. Officers often do appear, a first absence can be excused, and the judge has discretion to vary the rules. A driver who arrives expecting a no-show and finds the officer present faces a hearing with no preparation, decided on clear and convincing evidence.

Plea bargaining is not available at TVB. There is no reduction to negotiate if the officer appears, so the hearing goes forward on the charge written. That is why the only safe plan is to prepare as if the officer will be there:

  • Read the summons closely. The violation code, the VTL section, and the officer’s description define what must be proven.
  • Prepare questions for the officer about position, distance, sight line, lighting, traffic, and how the violation was observed.
  • Bring photos of the location, diagrams, dashcam footage, and any documents that support the defense.
  • Pull the DMV driving abstract so the point and suspension consequences are clear before the hearing starts.
  • Arrive early. TVB offices do not take walk-ins, so bring the hearing notice and photo ID.

Our post on what a TVB hearing in NYC involves walks through the hearing itself.

Does the Officer No-Show Rule Apply Outside TVB?

No. 15 NYCRR 124.9 applies only to TVB hearings on non-criminal moving violations. Criminal traffic cases in New York City Criminal Court, DMV chemical test refusal hearings, and parking or camera tickets at the NYC Department of Finance each follow different rules when a witness does not appear.

  • Criminal Court: DWI, reckless driving, and aggravated unlicensed operation are prosecuted by the District Attorney, and witness absences are handled under criminal procedure, including speedy trial rules.
  • Refusal hearings: under 15 NYCRR 127.9, a DMV hearing officer at a later refusal hearing can decide the case from the refusal report and other evidence even if the officer is absent. See our breath test refusal page for that process.
  • Parking and camera tickets: there is usually no officer testimony at all, because the case rests on the ticket or the camera record.

How Does Craig Bondy Handle Officer No-Shows at TVB?

Craig Bondy prepares every TVB hearing as if the officer will appear and contest every point, while tracking the record on each adjournment. When the officer is absent, our NYC traffic ticket defense practice asks the reason on the record, objects when the rule supports it, and moves for dismissal under 15 NYCRR 124.9.

That work includes reviewing the summons and the driver’s abstract, preparing cross-examination, handling the driver’s one reschedule when it helps, and keeping a clear record of each hearing date in case a TVB appeal to the DMV Appeals Board is needed. Our post on appealing a traffic court decision in New York City explains that step. No outcome can be promised, and no one can predict whether an officer will appear, but a driver who is ready for both possibilities is in the strongest position on hearing day.

Have a TVB hearing coming up and not sure what to expect if the officer is or isn’t there? Contact us now for a free consultation with The Law Office of Craig Bondy, and have your ticket prepared before your hearing date.

Sources

FacebookTwitterLinkedIn

Categories

Archives

Recent Posts

Call 212-257-8321 to receive a free, no-obligation ticket evaluation from The Law Office of Craig Bondy or reach us by email.

Contact Our team Today

Fields marked with an * are required

craig bondy cares. he wants to win as much as you do.

Contact Our Firm

The Law Office of
Craig Bondy

225 Broadway, Room 850
New York, NY 10007
phone: 212-257-8321

Email Us
New York Office

Click Scroll