Call For A Free Consultation 212-257-8321

Habla Español

What Is the Forfeit After Four Rule in New York?

What Is the Forfeit After Four Rule in New York?

The Forfeit After Four rule in New York is a DMV regulation that permanently denies a driver’s license to anyone with four alcohol- or drug-related driving convictions or incidents over a lifetime. It took effect January 3, 2025, lowering the old lifetime limit from five, and it also tightens relicensing for drivers with three.

For a New York City driver with one or two prior DWI or DWAI matters, a new arrest in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, or Staten Island now carries a consequence that reaches past the criminal case: it can move the driver closer to never holding a New York license again. Craig M. Bondy of The Law Office of Craig Bondy defends drivers charged with DWI and DWAI across the five boroughs and reviews full DMV records before relicensing applications. More on that side of the practice is on our New York City DWI defense page.

If you have a pending DWI, DWAI, or refusal case and prior alcohol- or drug-related matters on your record, contact our office for a free consultation before your next court date or DMV hearing.

What Does the Forfeit After Four Rule Do?

The Forfeit After Four rule tells the DMV Commissioner to deny any relicensing application from a person with four or more alcohol- or drug-related driving convictions or incidents, in any combination, within that person’s lifetime. Before January 3, 2025, the lifetime limit was five. The rule is in 15 NYCRR 136.5(b)(1).

The rule works through relicensing. A DWI conviction or a chemical test refusal finding revokes a New York license, and a revoked license does not come back on its own. When the revocation period ends, the driver must apply to the DMV for a new license. At that point, the DMV conducts a lifetime review of the entire driving record under 15 NYCRR Part 136. If the record shows four or more alcohol- or drug-related convictions or incidents, the application is denied.

The DMV announced the change as a way to remove persistently impaired drivers from the road. In practice, it means a fourth alcohol- or drug-related matter on a lifetime record is now the end of New York driving privileges, not a fifth.

What Counts as an Alcohol- or Drug-Related Conviction or Incident?

Under 15 NYCRR 136.5(a)(1), the count includes DWI and DWAI convictions under VTL 1192, out-of-state impaired-driving convictions, Zero Tolerance findings for drivers under 21, chemical test refusal findings, and Penal Law convictions where a VTL 1192 violation is an element. Matters from the same incident count once.

  • VTL 1192 convictions: any DWI or DWAI conviction, including DWAI-alcohol (the traffic infraction often reached as a reduced plea), DWAI-drugs, aggravated DWI, and per se DWI. A youthful offender adjudication for a VTL 1192 offense also counts.
  • Out-of-state convictions: a conviction for impaired driving in another state counts toward the New York lifetime total.
  • Zero Tolerance findings: a finding under VTL 1192-a that a driver under 21 drove after drinking. These findings drop out of the count once the retention period in VTL 201 expires.
  • Chemical test refusal findings: a DMV refusal finding under VTL 1194 counts as its own incident, unless it came from the same incident that produced a VTL 1192 conviction. A refusal finding under VTL 1194-a (the under-21 version) also counts.
  • Penal Law convictions: crimes such as vehicular assault or vehicular manslaughter, where a VTL 1192 violation is an essential element.

The refusal point surprises many drivers. A person who refused a breath test and was later acquitted of DWI, or whose criminal case was dismissed, can still have a refusal finding from the separate DMV refusal hearing. That finding counts toward four.

What Happens to a Driver With Three Alcohol- or Drug-Related Offenses?

A driver with three alcohol- or drug-related convictions or incidents within 25 years faces either permanent denial or a long wait. With a serious driving offense in the same 25 years, the DMV must deny relicensing. Without one, the DMV denies the application for at least two or five years beyond the statutory revocation period.

The 25-year look-back period runs from 25 years before the date of the revocable offense (the offense that caused the current revocation) through that date. Within that window, 15 NYCRR 136.5(b) sets three outcomes for a driver with three alcohol- or drug-related matters:

  • Three matters plus a serious driving offense: the DMV must deny the application (136.5(b)(2)).
  • Three matters, no serious driving offense, and a current alcohol- or drug-related revocation: denial for at least five years beyond the statutory revocation period. A later approval comes with an A2 restricted license for five years and an ignition interlock device on any vehicle the person owns or operates during that period (136.5(b)(3)).
  • Three matters, no serious driving offense, and no current alcohol- or drug-related revocation: denial for at least two years beyond the statutory revocation period, followed by an A2 restricted license for two years without an interlock requirement (136.5(b)(4)).

An A2 restriction limits driving to set purposes, such as travel to and from work, school, or medical treatment. The waiting period is extended by another five years (or two years, for the shorter track) if the DMV finds the person drove during the wait, shown by accidents, convictions, or pending tickets. A later revocation for another alcohol- or drug-related matter, or for a conviction arising from a fatal crash, makes the person ineligible for any license.

A driver with two alcohol- or drug-related matters within 25 years can be relicensed in the Commissioner’s discretion after the minimum statutory revocation period (136.5(b)(5)).

What Is a Serious Driving Offense Under the DMV Rules?

A serious driving offense under 15 NYCRR 136.5(a)(2) is a fatal accident, a driving-related Penal Law conviction, two or more convictions that each carry five or more points, or 20 or more points from violations other than alcohol- or drug-related matters, all within the 25-year look-back period.

The two-violations-at-five-points category is broader than most drivers expect. The Appellate Division upheld the DMV’s use of two ordinary speeding tickets to deny relicensing to a driver with three alcohol-related matters. The changes to the DMV point schedule for violations on or after February 16, 2026 also raised several common violations to five points or more:

  • Failure to exercise due care (VTL 1146): 5 points, up from 2
  • Leaving the scene of a personal injury crash (VTL 600): 5 points, up from 3
  • Passing a stopped school bus (VTL 1174): 8 points, up from 5
  • Speeding in a construction zone: 8 points regardless of speed
  • Speeding 21 or more mph over the limit: 6 points or more

For a New York City driver with three alcohol- or drug-related matters already on record, two of these tickets within 25 years can turn a two-year or five-year wait into a permanent denial. That makes an ordinary TVB ticket worth contesting. The 11 points now assigned to an alcohol- or drug-related conviction do not count toward the 20-point category, because that category excludes alcohol- and drug-related matters.

Are There Other Ways to Lose a New York License Permanently?

Yes. Under 15 NYCRR 136.5(b)(6), the DMV must deny relicensing to a person with two convictions for DWI, DWAI-drugs, or DWAI-combined influence where each crash caused physical injury, as defined in Penal Law 10.00. The Commissioner’s discretionary exception does not apply to that denial.

A separate track applies after a fatal crash. A driver revoked for an alcohol-related conviction involving a fatal accident, and otherwise eligible, can be relicensed only in the Commissioner’s discretion, with an A2 restriction and an ignition interlock for three years (136.5(b)(7)).

Can the DMV Make an Exception to Forfeit After Four?

The DMV Commissioner may approve an application that the rules would otherwise deny if there are unusual, extenuating, and compelling circumstances, under 15 NYCRR 136.5(d). The reasons must be written and recorded, and the license can carry a problem driver restriction and an ignition interlock requirement for up to five years.

This exception is narrow and discretionary. It does not apply to the two-injury-convictions denial in 136.5(b)(6), and nothing in the rule requires the DMV to grant it. A driver who intends to ask for it needs a documented record: proof of treatment and sobriety, the circumstances of each prior matter, a clean driving history since the last revocation, and the hardship a permanent denial would cause.

Pending tickets also matter at this stage. If a driver has two alcohol- or drug-related matters on record and a pending alcohol- or drug-related ticket that would require denial on conviction, the DMV holds the relicensing review in abeyance until the ticket is resolved (136.5(e)).

Why Does Every DWI, DWAI, or Refusal Charge Matter More Now?

Every DWI, DWAI, and refusal charge matters more because each conviction or finding is one of four lifetime strikes, and since February 16, 2026 each also carries 11 DMV points. A plea that once looked minor, such as DWAI-alcohol, still counts as a full alcohol-related conviction under the relicensing rules.

That changes how a first or second arrest in New York City should be approached. Before deciding on a plea, a driver should know the full lifetime count, including old out-of-state convictions, Zero Tolerance findings, and refusal findings from years ago. Our post on what happens if you refuse a breathalyzer explains the refusal hearing, and our post on how many points a DWI carries in NYC covers the 2026 point change.

  • The DMV refusal hearing is separate from the criminal case, and a refusal finding counts even if the criminal charge is dismissed.
  • Under VTL 1192(10), plea bargaining in a DWI case is limited, and the most common reduction, DWAI-alcohol, is still an alcohol-related conviction for Part 136 purposes.
  • A third or fourth alcohol- or drug-related matter can also bring felony charges and longer criminal sentences, separate from the DMV consequences.

How Does Craig Bondy Handle Cases Where Forfeit After Four Is at Stake?

Craig Bondy starts with a lifetime record review: the DMV abstract, every alcohol- or drug-related matter, every five-point violation, and the 25-year window. From that record, our New York City DWI defense practice decides how to defend the new charge, the refusal hearing, and any later relicensing application.

In the criminal case, that means reviewing the stop, the arrest, the breath or blood test, and the instrument’s calibration and maintenance records, and raising suppression issues where the record supports them. At the DMV refusal hearing, it means holding the officer to each element the DMV must find. For a driver whose revocation is ending, it means preparing the relicensing application with the full record in view, including any argument for the Commissioner’s discretionary exception. Our lifetime review of your entire record page explains how that review works. No outcome can be promised, but the count of four is built one case at a time, and each case can be contested.

Worried that a new DWI, DWAI, or refusal charge could cost you your license for good? Contact us now for a free consultation with The Law Office of Craig Bondy, and have your full driving record reviewed before your next court date or DMV hearing.

Sources

FacebookTwitterLinkedIn

Categories

Archives

Recent Posts

Call 212-257-8321 to receive a free, no-obligation ticket evaluation from The Law Office of Craig Bondy or reach us by email.

Contact Our team Today

Fields marked with an * are required

craig bondy cares. he wants to win as much as you do.

Contact Our Firm

The Law Office of
Craig Bondy

225 Broadway, Room 850
New York, NY 10007
phone: 212-257-8321

Email Us
New York Office

Click Scroll